In Depth
Why are international agreements often not enough?
Cooperation is indispensable. But between a shared commitment and its implementation there is often a gap.
- Last updated:
- Reading time:
- 7 min
In Brief
- Some problems exceed the capacity of a single state: climate, pandemics, nuclear proliferation, artificial intelligence and other transnational risks.
- Multilateralism enables common rules and shared responsibility, but its effectiveness depends on clear commitments, verification, incentives, resources, representation and implementation.
- The Pact for the Future, adopted by United Nations member states in 2024, recognizes that current challenges are interconnected and exceed the capacity of any single state.
- The same document calls for a more effective, capable, just, democratic, equitable and representative multilateral system.
What we know
Documented facts
- The Pact for the Future was adopted by UN member states in 2024 and explicitly addresses the transformation of global governance.
- The document recognizes the interconnection of global challenges and the fact that no state can address them alone.
- The chapter on transforming global governance points to the need for a more effective, representative, equitable and democratic multilateral system.
- The acknowledgement of the limits of the current multilateral system is thus a fact shared by the states themselves, not a partisan opinion.
How sure are we?
Solid evidence
Numerous studies and authoritative sources converge.
It is solid evidence that problems are transnational in character and that states recognize institutional limits of the multilateral system. The concrete shape of a future global governance remains an open question and, as far as No-Extinction is concerned, a proposal.
How it can be read
Interpretations
- The gap between commitment and implementation depends less on a lack of declared will and more on the absence of verification tools and consequences for non-compliance.
- More global capacity does not mean centralising everything: it means assigning to the global level only what the global level can truly resolve.
What we don't know
- We do not know which institutional reforms would prove effective in practice: historical experiences are not easily generalised.
- It is not clear which verification and enforcement mechanisms are politically acceptable to a sufficient number of states.
- We do not know in advance the correct balance between global decision-making capacity and local autonomy for each subject matter.
Why it matters
- If agreements remain mere declarations, global risks keep accumulating while trust in cooperation declines.
- The quality of representation determines who has a voice in decisions that affect everyone.
- Any new global decision-making capacity, without checks, would itself be a risk.
What we can do
- Apply the principle of subsidiarity: local what can be local, national what can be national, global only what truly requires the global level.
- Assess international agreements by looking at verification, resources and implementation mechanisms, not only announced goals.
- Ask for transparency in international decision-making processes.
The No-Extinction proposal
Proposals
- No-Extinction proposal, distinct from the official positions of the United Nations: strengthen decision-making capacity on genuinely global issues, with a narrow mandate, transparency, competence, independent checks, representation and explicit safeguards against abuses of power.
Sources and data
The links lead to the original documents and open in a new tab. Every figure cited in this article comes from these sources.
United Nations
Pact for the Future
official document · 2024
www.un.org/pact-for-the-future/en/pact-future-0(opens in a new tab)United Nations
Chapter V — Transforming global governance
official document · 2024
www.un.org/pact-for-the-future/en/chapter-v-transforming-global-governance(opens in a new tab)United Nations
About the Pact for the Future
information page · 2024
www.un.org/pact-for-the-future/en/about-pact(opens in a new tab)